On a visit to Israel in 2010, Biden used to be caught off guard when authorities announced plans to build hundreds of new homes in the sprawling Jewish settlement in east Jerusalem. The incident embarrassed Biden and sparked a diplomatic rift with the Obama administration that never fairly healed. Yet despite Biden’s opposition to the project, a decade later Ramat Shlomo has ballooned.
The episode could foreshadow what lies ahead under the Biden administration — with a US president objected to Israeli construction on occupied lands claimed by the Palestinians but seemingly limited in his ability to stop it, especially when dealing with a changing Middle East and preoccupied by domestic priorities.
The coming two months supply a key test for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on the matter. The Israeli leader, a longtime supporter of the settlements, may seek to make the most of the last days of the settlement-friendly Trump administration and push through a flurry of last-minute construction projects. But doing so could antagonize the incoming administration.
Both settlement supporters and critics expect Netanyahu to proceed with caution. With the Biden administration expected to re-engage with Iran over its nuclear program, Netanyahu’s top security concern, he seems unlikely to pick out a fight with the president-elect. Netanyahu’s office did not respond to a request for remark.
Martin Indyk, a former US peace negotiator throughout the Clinton and Obama administrations, said the Israeli-Palestinian clash is no longer a “imperative national interest” for Washington and that he did not expect Biden to make it a precedence. Nonetheless, he said Biden still has a strong familiarity with the region.
“I don’t think he’s going to need to have a fight over settlements. But whether Bibi makes it an issue, then there will be a problem there,” said Indyk, the use of Netanyahu’s nickname.
Trump has delivered various diplomatic gifts to Netanyahu, including the withdrawal of the United States from the international nuclear handle Iran, recognition of Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and moving the United States Embassy there. Trump recently brokered three normalization deals between Israel and Arab countries, shattering a longstanding position by Arab states that have traditionally withheld recognizing Israel until it made major concessions to the Palestinians.
In a break from his Republican and Democratic predecessors, Trump also has taken a much softer line toward the settlements. Surrounded by advisers with near ties to the settler movement, Trump’s administration declared final year that it did not imagine the settlements to be unlawful under international law. Then, in January, he unveiled a Mideast plan that envisions placing parts of the West Bank, including the entire settlements, under permanent Israeli keep watch over.
Israel this year appeared poised to start annexing West Bank territory under the Trump plan but used to be dissuaded as a part of the deal establishing ties with the United Arab Emirates. Nonetheless, Israel has ramped up plans to build thousands of new homes during the West Bank. Anti-settlement monitoring groups expect extra settlement approvals in the West Bank and east Jerusalem before the end of Trump’s term.
Biden, while claiming to have “ironclad” make stronger for Israel, has already indicated he’ll reverse many of Trump’s decisions. He has come out against unilateral annexation and supports a two-state solution between Israel and the Palestinians. Even though he has said he’ll not move the embassy back to Tel Aviv, he’s expected to reopen the United States Consulate in Jerusalem that managed relations with the Palestinians and restore hundreds of millions of dollars of aid to the Palestinians that Trump bring to an end.
Palestinian official Hanan Ashrawi called on the incoming administration not to go back to “mistakes of the past” and said the traditional US condemnations of settlement expansion would not be enough.
“There will have to be accountability and consequences whether Israel continues its settlement policies,” she said. “In a different way, what is going to be the advantage of statements of condemnation whether Israel continues with expansion and settlements?”
The Palestinians, with wide international backing, seek the entire West Bank and east Jerusalem, captured by Israel in 1967, as parts of a future independent state. With almost 500,000 settlers now living in the West Bank, and over 220,000 more in east Jerusalem, the Palestinians say the chances of establishing their state are quickly dwindling.
Preceding American administrations viewed settlements as illegitimate and obstacles to peace. President Barack Obama took an even harsher tack and repeatedly clashed with Netanyahu over new construction. Weeks before leaving office, Obama allowed the U.N. Security Council to pass a resolution declaring the settlements unlawful.
A nadir in those ties came at Biden’s expense with the 2010 Ramat Shlomo incident. As he held friendly meetings with Israeli officials, Israel’s Interior Ministry approved the construction of 1,600 new apartments in the neighbourhood. Netanyahu said at the time that he had been blindsided by the announcement by low-level technocrats and tried to contain the damage at a late-night dinner with Biden.
Nonetheless, Biden issued a harshly worded commentary, saying the approvals undermined believe.
At the time, Ramat Shlomo had approximately 2,000 apartments, according to Ir Amim, a group that tracks settlement building in Jerusalem.
Today, the area, which Israel considers a neighborhood of its capital, is undergoing a construction boom, with almost 600 homes being built, according to Peace Now, another anti-settlement monitoring group. Ir Amim says over 700 extra apartments are in the pipeline. This week, bulldozers shoveled dirt and cranes whirred in the community’s building frenzy.
Brian Reeves, a spokesman for Peace Now, said the group expects Biden to change the tone on settlements but not to put enough pressure on Israel to stop.
“America will renew its condemnations of settlements but it’s not going to take any drastic action against it, so it’s going to appear find it irresistible’s ringing hollow,” he said.
Settler leaders, disappointed to be losing a friend in Trump, said they hope Biden will be different than Obama and not push for curbs on construction.
“I would hope that they don’t fall back into the old approach that led us into a impasse,” said Oded Revivi, mayor of the Efrat settlement.
For now, Israel seems unlikely to make too many bold moves in the settlements whether it wants to curry favor with an administration likely to renegotiate the Iran nuclear deal.
“The No. 1 issue for Israel is Iran. Not the settlements, not the peace process, not the Palestinians,” said Eytan Gilboa, an expert on US-Israel relations. “Anything that could disrupt collaboration with the US on Iran is going to be off.”